Scientific event

Men of Virtue and Generosity: Tolerance and Peaceful Coexistence in Spiritual Experiences
Men of Virtue and Generosity: Tolerance and Peaceful Coexistence in Spiritual Experiences
National Seminar
25/05/2026 14:00 CRASC
Imagination and Social Processes Division
thematiques
The Religious Sphere and Religious Practices
Abstract
Summary of the seminar
This round table proposes to explore, in a nuanced manner, how spiritual traditions—particularly Sufism in its Islamic and Christian contexts—rethink the relationship to the Other at the heart of social life. It is structured around an essential question: is Sufism limited to promoting a moral discourse on tolerance, or does it offer concrete ways of living out difference and building a peaceful coexistence in daily life? The guiding idea is that, far from being reduced to a mere acceptance of the other, tolerance here becomes a living relationship, both ethical and existential, embodied in social practices.
From this perspective, tolerance is not understood as a passive attitude of "enduring" difference, but as an active way of rethinking it to avoid exclusion. Similarly, peaceful coexistence is not reduced to the absence of conflict: it is built through ordinary gestures, through generosity, mediation, and the concrete recognition of the other. Philosophical reflections shed light on this dynamic. Thus, in Ibn ‘Arabî’s thought, tolerance is rooted in a vision of truth that combines unity and diversity: a single origin, but multiple manifestations. This conception allows for the embrace of difference without denying it, paving the way for what might be called an "existential tolerance." Conversely, in Augustine’s view, peace rests on an "order of charity," where harmony arises from an arrangement of relationships centered on a single spiritual truth, giving rise to a more structured form of coexistence.

Yet, these ideas do not remain abstract. Spiritual experiences show that tolerance and living together are also built through practice: dhikr, samā‘, or hospitality are not mere rituals, but moments where bonds are woven, and where the boundaries between self and other become more flexible. They give rise to genuine "sensitive communities," where peace is experienced as a lifestyle, shaped by forgiveness, welcome, and openness.
In this sense, spirituality emerges as a powerful factor for social cohesion. It fosters forms of solidarity, in the sense of Émile Durkheim, and helps soothe tensions. It also generates symbolic capital based on moral recognition and generosity, as demonstrated by Pierre Bourdieu. "Men of virtue and generosity" then play an essential role: they transmit values, perpetuate a memory of love, and act as mediators within society.
Thus, spiritual experience does not merely produce a discourse on tolerance: it shapes a way of living together, where difference is integrated rather than excluded, and where peace becomes a daily practice.
However, a certain critical distance must be maintained. These forms of coexistence remain tied to specific historical and social contexts. They do not rely on the abstract legal and philosophical frameworks of modern societies, but rather on ethical and symbolic balances that are sometimes fragile and evolving. Hence an important question: to what extent can these experiences inspire, today, more institutionalized models of living together?
Participants
Djilali EL MESTARI
Djilali EL MESTARI
Moderator
Biography
Dr. Djilali ELMESTARI is a Principal Research Associate at the Centre of Research in Social
and Cultural Anthropology/ CRASC (Oran, Algeria). He holds a habilitation and a Ph.D. in
Philosophy of Religion from the University of Oran. He held the position of Director of the
Centre of Research in Social and Cultural Anthropology (2017- 2021), and the position of
Director General of the National Institute for Research in Education/ INRE, Algeria (2016-
2017).
El Mestari’s area of interest includes themes related to religious discourse, education and
citizenship, and community issues.
He has participated in several international and national projects, including two ongoing
research projects conducted by the CRASC: “The Production of Religious Knowledge in
Official Religious Institutions: case of the University of Religious Sciences in Constantine”
and “Textbooks of School Subjects Related to Social Sciences and Humanities (1963-2020)”.
In the last two years, he has been a Visiting Professor at the University of Padua, Italy: The
International Master in Religion, Politics and Global Society.
Among his most important and recent scientific production:
- 2022. Coordinator with Khalid Rhazzali and Dafne Accoroni (from Italy) of the 95/96 issues
of Insaniyat Journal on "Socioanthropology of Religion in the Mediterranean Region"
- 2022. Co-editor with Soraya Mouloudji of the collective book “Society and the Pandemic”,
Publisher: CRASC.
In addition to three research papers addressing themes of religious and educational discourse
in Algeria:
- 2022. Co-author of “Youth and the Discourse of Religious Referents in Algeria. Results
of Field Surveys”. Insaniyat, Part 1, No. 95
- 2022. “The Institutionalized Religious Discourse During the First Period of the
Pandemic in Algeria”. Society and the Pandemic
- 2021. The Second Generation of Islamic Education Textbooks in Algeria: Contents and
Challenges. Published by the Higher Islamic Council